This article reviews lots of rosés and makes a note about some that will be particularly friendly with the wide array of foods provided at most Thanksgiving dinners. Pink wine shouldn't have a season.
A special salute and thank you to Beth at Swirl who held a tasting of 15(!) rosés on November 22nd! It was brilliant and gutsy and, I hope, successful.
When I lived in Portland, Oregon rosés went on sale in September. Demand dropped with the temperature. I stocked up knowing I would want a little reminder of summer during the wet, rainy winter. In NOLA, on the other hand, rosé remains a wise choice pretty much year round. Even if the pool isn’t quite as appealing, a porch or picnic might still call your name.
Pink wines pair beautifully with all sorts of food and are all but guaranteed to put a smile on your face. With that in mind, here are most of the rosés that have crossed my palate over the summer and into the fall. All of them were purchased in New Orleans at the following places: Kiefe & Co., Martin Wine Cellar, Swirl, Bin 428, Pearl and Rouse’s (specifically at Napoleon and Tchoupitoulas). Many are certainly available elsewhere. Importers are noted where appropriate to make it easier for your favorite retailer to track some bottles down.
Some of these may have sold out but you'll be able to find others. My thoughts on food are shared as well, sometimes a wine takes me to a very specific thoughts, but remember rosés are incredibly versatile and I find very few foods that don’t pair with well with pink. My top Thanksgiving choices are marked accordingly.
Where I have experienced year in and year out happiness from a bottling, I have marked noted that so you can buy with confidence when the new vintage is released. (I thought about putting a Pharrell mountie hat on them to signify ‘Happy’ but I’m pretty sure the heavy rotation of that song has left a bad taste in some people’s mouths and that shouldn't be held against the wine.) Where available there is information about their environmental practices, because the earth is important.
This is a long post, it was originally supposed to be a two part series for a local website. They never ran it and I reclaimed my rights so I could share some gems with my readers in time for Thanksgiving! I considered breaking it into two posts but decided to let it rip. There are plenty of pictures...and I know you can handle it!
In no particular order but grouped together by country:
Plouzeau Chateau de la Bonneliére Chinon Rosé, Rive Gauche 2013
Imported by Weygandt Metzler - This is made from cabernet franc in the Loire Valley, the appellation is Chinon. The grapes are farmed biodynamically (super -organic) and the specific site, Rive Gauche, is located on the river.
Orange-salmon color, delicate but not wimpy. Lovely balance, dry but mouthwatering. Tasty. Some orange fruit notes, great texture, mouthwatering (again, it was dancing on my tongue) and LONG! Nothing wrong with sipping but this would love some shellfish and hard, mild cheese. $15
Good Thanksgiving choice.
Charles Joguet Chinon Rosé 2013
Imported by Kermit Lynch - For years this was my favorite pink wine. The Joguets made wines that defied easy categorization - wild and untamed but not sloppy. While I believe the man in charge now, Kevin Fontaine, and his team do a good job, the wines are different.
He employs lutte raisonnée, which essentially means chemicals are okay to use if you must but should be avoided.
The color for the last few years has been much more pink but this version found a nice middle ground, showing salmon and orange more than vibrant pink. The first pour displayed some spritz, was long and creamy but remained fresh. Delicious. Great weight, rich, tactile, long, persistent. Real wine...serious but also enjoyable if you’re not paying attention. Grilled fish and meats seem about right for this wine. $18
Consistent and a good Thanksgiving choice.
Dom de la Noblaie Chinon Goutte de Rosé 2013
Imported by European Cellars - Situated on a fairly high point in Chinon, all grapes are hand harvested. The winery is certified organic and the grape in this wine is 100% cabernet franc.
This was darker than the other two Chinons. It looked almost brown in the bottle until held up to a white sheet of paper where it was clearly more pink. In the glass it was a little of both. The wine was a little dirty on the nose, tasty enough but simple. It was outclassed by the other Chinons but tasted okay on its own. Overall, a good representation but not worth searching for. $18
Domaine de la Sanglière Juliette, Provence 2013
Imported by Turquoise Life - This is a new winery to me and I am thrilled to have found it. They talk of an organic approach but are not certified. They do not employ weed killers or insecticide.
The wine is 70% grenache and 30% syrah, a classic blend. The color is also classic Provencal rosé, pink with a pronounced orange hue. You will not find exotic berry fruit but you will find a silky feel and plenty of pleasure. The palate shows some orange peel and subtle strawberry while the wonderful acidity makes my mouth water so much the impression the wine leaves behind is, ironically, one of sweetness. The wine is actually so dry it makes your mouth water. It is also rich enough to feel full-bodied without getting heavy. This is classic and delicious and I bought some (not enough) at Swirl's tasting. $13-$14
Good Thanksgiving choice (and, I hope, consistent because I love it and the price!).
Domaine de Reuilly, Reuilly Rosé 2013
Imported by Kermit Lynch - [Note: this is not the rosé label, I missed taking pictures of a few, but it looks just like this except with pink print]
This estate is nearly single-handedly making more people aware of this appellation. In the past this pinot noir rosé has been hard to appreciate unless you aged it for a year (or more) or opened the wine the day before to let it open up.
Farming is done organically and biodynamically.
Immediately, it was obvious there was much more color than I remember but still much more orange than pink. The wine remains RACY but is now enjoyable right out of the bottle. The juicy feel and subtle strawberry provide just enough balance. It got even better with time. For fans of crisp wines with plenty of acid. Seems like some bread, mild cheese and maybe some olive tapenade might be ideal. Salads too. $26
Domaine Faillenc Sainte Marie Rosé des Glacières 2013
Imported by Neal Rosenthal - From southern France, Corbieres to be specific - although this bottle carries the generic Vin de France designation. The rocky, windswept region naturally keeps yields down and concentrates flavors. The vineyard is farmed organically and this wine is 100% syrah. It used to have a small amount of residual sugar but not for the last few years.
The color is deep and the nose screams of strawberry extract. It is intense and wild, just like the area where the grapes grow. This wine had been open a few days before I tried it and had clearly lost some verve but still showed well, which is an amazing thing to say about any wine, especially a pink one. Tasty. Serve this one to a devoted red wine drinker who swears he/she does not enjoy rosés. Real pink wine fans will love it too. This would play well with grilled meat, pastas and rich cheeses. $17
Consistent and a good Thanksgiving choice if you're serving meat instead of poultry.
Domaine La Manarine Cotes du Rhone Rosé 2013
Imported by Neal Rosenthal - A classic southern Rhone producer with plenty of rocks in the vineyards and lots of limestone, which leads to a minerally style. The blend is approximately, 60% grenache, 20% mourvedre and 20% syrah.
The color is very evocative of southern France, orange and salmon. The aromas have some notes of orange also with grapefruit, lemon and some red but racy, acid-driven fruit. The acidity is wonderful and tingly. Watermelon shows up again here and it is intense. This is a big mouthful of wine! I wanted pasta with pancetta, herbs de Provence and lots of garlic. Or a plate of cured meats, some goat cheese and a view. Or door number three...all of the above! $16 I know this is sold out at Kiefe & Co. where I bought it but it’s possible you’ll find some around town. If not, snag some next year.
Consistent and a good Thanksgiving choice.
Chateau Famaey, Malbec Rosé 2013
Imported by Scott Levy Selections - From southwest France, essentially Cahors - the home of malbec. The winery says they’re “semi-organic” and then explains they avoid chemicals unless absolutely necessary (lutte raissonée). 100% malbec.
Another one with that Kool-aid color. The wine is soft, simple and easy. The palate is juicier than many others. There is not much happening in the glass but there is nothing wrong either. This is porch wine, pure and simple. It might pair with a lot of food but nothing jumped at me. $10
L’Argentier Aramon Rosé 2013
Imported by Fruit of the Vines - The Jourdan family have run the estate for nearly 80 years. The wine is 100% aramon, (it’s okay, I had to look it up). It used to be a very widely planted variety but is described by Jancis Robinson as “coarse, high-yielding” and referred to as a “workhorse grape.” Hardly a ringing endorsement, but certainly explains why I’d never heard of it.
This was pretty big with a dark color, easily observed through the clear glass. It also has some meat on its bones and wants to be at the table...or wherever you choose to eat food. A nuance of orange, both sweet and tart, appeared and my impression of the wine on my tongue was softness and luxury, like my mouth was relaxing in a velvet hammock near a lake (I was near a lake, maybe wishing for a hammock). Watermelon shone through also, like so many others I have tasted lately. This is really delicious and has good weight for the red wine drinker. The finish is long and somewhere between the edginess of minerality and the lushness described earlier. There is also an oily, earthy note that I can only try to pin down for you, reminding me of fresh sardines and their intense salinity. Grilled sardines sounds perfect but grilled meat (lamb!) and grilled shrimp sound easier to acquire. Olives and pesto pasta also spring to mind. $15
Consistent (two years) and a good Thanksgiving choice.
Jaboulet Parallèle 45, Cotes du Rhone Rosé 2013
Imported by Frederick Wildman & Sons - The 45th parallel is a mere two kilometers from their cellars. Jaboulet produces a wide range of wines from the Rhone Valley. They do an excellent job from top to bottom. This is a blend of 50% grenache, 40% cinsault and 10% syrah.
Pale pink, atlantic salmon color with plenty of mineral and not much else very distinct. It was tasty enough but didn’t wow me. When I poured a second taste, it made sense, the wine was corked. It was unnoticeable at first, only showing that telltale wet cardboard taste (and a hint on the nose) with time and some air. This is a decent wine for a good price but a reminder why all bottles in this style - fresh, meant to be consumed young - should be sealed with a screwcap. A fine choice for the money when it isn’t tainted. $11
Consistent and a good Thanksgiving choice - assuming you get a bottle the way it is supposed to be.
Tintero, Grangia Moscato Rosato 2013
Imported by Kermit Lynch - The winery is in Piedmont, a sweet spot for moscato grapes (sorry, couldn’t resist. You may not see that noted on the bottle since they source from around the appellation. The winery farms sustainably.
This is a bit of a kitchen sink blend: barbera, moscato, favorita and some arneis, at least. Some almond notes shine through - that comes from the arneis. Great watermelon color. Lovely texture, good depth, subtle on finish. Nice balance, a bit short but not un-rewarding. Mouthwatering - (underlined in my notes). Perfect for whetting the appetite or as a light dessert wine with perhaps some nuts or biscotti. Also fantastic as a refreshment for the grill master or gardener. 11.5% alcohol means you can enjoy the flavor without getting tipsy too quickly. $14
La Spinetta Il Rosato di Casanova, Tuscany 2013
Imported by Indigenous Selections - locally Lirette Selections - The winery is well known and respected for their full-flavored wines that speak of the Italian roots but exhibit more polish and immediate pleasure than many other neighbors. They are 75% biodynamic (no idea of the vineyards not included) and use no chemical products, fertilizers or pesticides. They produce in Piedmont and Tuscany. This wine is 50% sangiovese (the base for Chianti) and 50% prugnolo gentile (don’t worry about it).
The color is a very light rosé color, it reminds me of copper. The palate is tangy with some earth on the finish - much more presence than the color would imply. The finish is nearly a lemon curd but less round than that sounds and with more pronounced acidity. Some fine tannin appears on the huge, long, mouthwatering finish. Despite all of my salmon color references, this was the fist wine that made we wish for the fish. $17-$18.
This could be a good Thanksgiving choice though I worry about it being overwhelmed.
Maiano Refrain Vino Spumante Extra Dry, Non-Vintage, Tuscany
I fell down on the job of drinking sparkling rosé, mea culpa. I will NOT let it happen again. This was another wonderful Swirl find. Bizarrely, this wine label is all in Italian and lists no importer, but a web search found Bon Vivant Imports.
The winery pursues a natural approach, avoiding herbicide and pesticide treatments.
The wine is 100% malvasia nera. I am amazed they use the charmat method to introduce bubbles. Usually, I find this process very obvious and sometimes even a little heavy-handed and clumsy. Instead of developing the bubbles in the bottle (as they do in Champagne and most high-end sparklers) CO2 is pumped into a tank and the bubbles develop there, the wine is bottled later.
The bubbles are fine and focused, and the wine is as well. While the website claims the wine is "a little bit sweet," I found it pretty dry and thoroughly enjoyable. Lovely red berry notes predominate and the focused mouthfeel made me want some food immediately. $15-$17
A good Thanksgiving choice
Vinho Verde is produced in the northwest of Spain and literally translates as ‘green wine.’ The rosés are the right color. rink them young, they do not age.
Casal Garcia, Vinho Verde Rosé
Imported by Alveda, Inc - This bottle seems not to display a vintage, always a warning sign to me, especially with simple rosé, and even more so with Vinho Verde. Approach with caution and buy from outlets that feature it prominently to ensure turnover. Made from Vinhao, Azal Tinto and Borracal (I know, me either).
The hallmark spritziness is present and delightful on the tongue. The color is bright, almost grenadine - and you can actually see the bubbles. The finish is short but the mid-palate is full. The sweet cherry middle avoids being cloying but is far from bone dry. Another quaffer at a mere 10.5% alcohol. $8
Consistent wine, just try to make sure you’re buying a current release.
Ela Vinho Verde Rosé 2013
Imported by Touchstone-Wines - There is precious little story about this winery but the price might mitigate a need for one. 60% vinhao, 30% borracal and 10% espadiero (again, me either).
There’s that vibrant Kool-aid color again. This was the sweetest of the pink wines we tried. Not bad though with some subtle spritz. This is beach wine. Uncomplicated but a bargain. Low alcohol also, 10%. $7-$8
Elk Cove Pinot Noir Rosé, Willamette Valley 2013
I adore this winery but have been disappointed in their rosé ever since I first tasted it. Too much fruit and not enough depth for my palate. Their vineyard practices are very much in keeping with an Oregon sensibility about sustainability, read more here.
The wine has a different color than in years past though the winemaking notes do not reflect a new approach. It looks pale to me, peach almost, quite a change. Rose petals on the nose with hints of citrus: lemon when the wine was cold and orange as it warmed. Watermelon on the finish! The texture is soft but has some weight. The wine is subtle, elegant and shows none of the sweetness like it has in the past. Yay! I wanted guacamole and chips, something salty. $15
Finally(!) a good Thanksgiving choice.
Crios Malbec Rosé, Mendoza 2012
Imported by Vine Connections - Susana Balbo (winemaker) is a genius. She’s not afraid of making big wines but they never become ponderous or unbalanced. The wine is 100% malbec. Although they do not share their viticultural practices, Mendoza requires very little chemical use because they do not have many pests and rarely experience mildew or rot issues.
The lone 2012 in the series. This was in the middle of color, not quite Faillenc but darker than Elk Cove. The wine was thick, tactile, rich and fairly heavy but not cloying at all. It shows lushness without being creamy. It wasn’t very complex but sometimes solid and big is enough. This is for cabernet drinkers. Cherry is the dominant flavor and it is dark, but not quite black. I wanted a steak salad or maybe some seared tuna with plenty of pepper. $14
Consistent and a good Thanksgiving choice.
The regions that produce the wines featured here rarely need much chemical attention in the vineyards. They do not have mold, mildew or pest issues allowing the wineries to operate in a sustainable way. That said, I do not have a clue about any of these wineries’ specifics.
Bodegas Muga Rosado, Rioja 2013
Imported by Jorge Ordonez, locally by Wines Unlimited - Muga is a very traditional producer that makes classic wines. The rosé has always excelled. 60% garnacha (grenache), 30% viura (white wine similar to sauvignon blanc) and 10% tempranillo (the classic grape of Rioja).
Great pink color, with citrus on the nose and some watermelon. The fruit is intense, not quite strawberry, and some oak shows through on the nose and palate. Great texture. A hint of earth emerges on the finish and the wine is clean and dry but not tannic. After it opened, it got a little soapy but the high acid remained. Overall, not as impressed as I have been but still a good value. I just wanted to drink this one, relaxing or cooking. Snacks are fine but not needed. $11
Consistent recommendation in the past but this year was a different style of wine.
Dominio de Eguren Protocolo Rosé 2013
Imported by Jorge Ordonez, locally by Wines Unlimited - From La Mancha, the official appellation is Vino de la Tierra de Castilla but what you need to know is that it is made from 70% bobal and 30% tempranillo.
There is very little to say about this wine. It’s pink, it was cold and it was simple. There is not much going on but for the price, how much do you expect? At this price, try it with everything. I give it 4 Ps...perfect pool/porch/party wine. $6
Consistent and a good Thanksgiving choice for a crowd.
Bodegas Borsao, Borsao Rosé, Campo de Borja 2013
Imported by Jorge Ordonez, locally by Wines Unlimited - Yes, the wine is named identically to the winery. No, they are not crazy, just confusing (confused?). The region of Campo de Borja is located immediately south and east of the more famous Rioja. The appellation’s signature grape is garnacha (grenache) and this wine is 100% that grape.
Although I am a huge fan of the winery, I have been iffy on this bottling in the past and this year didn’t change my impression. It lacks complexity and there’s too much sweetness for my palate. This wine is a throwaway for me and I would rather save $2 and drink the Protocolo. I had no interest in pairing this with anything except maybe some tonic and vodka. $8
Weingut Familie Juak Schilcher Klassic, Blauer Wildbacher 2013
Imported by Haus Alpenz - There is precious little out there about this wine but here’s what I know. It comes from Styria in the southeast of Austria. Schilcher is a style of rosé wine, including sparkling. Christian Jauk makes a few Schilcher wines, this is their ‘classic.’ The grape, Blauer Wildbacher, is dark-skinned, obvious when you see the vibrant hue of the wine. Blauer means ‘blue’ in German and is used to describe grapes with deeper color.
Looks like Kool-Aid. Wow, insane acid! The long, layered attack is mesmerizing and the wine is rich and untamed. It makes my mouth water for a long time...a really long time. I wanted cured meats and washed rind cheese. Nothing civilized for this wine, maybe ribs...this wants food with a bone or venison. Maybe just a similarly wild guest. $17
Good Thanksgiving choice with wild fowl or meats.
Mulderbosch Rosé, Coastal Region 2013
Imported by Mulderbosch - The winery participates in the BWI (Biodiversity and Wine Initiative) addressing the vineyards and their surrounding flora and fauna. I have been a huge fan of this winery but it was bought out and the long time winemaker, Mike Dobrovic, left. The new owner, Charles Banks, has been acquiring wineries left and right and this approach rarely bodes well. I wrote a short piece about this specifically referencing Mulderbosch about a year ago (read it here). Production was slated to grow, quickly. If this is the result of the new ownership I do not need to pay attention to this winery anymore.
No longer big and brawny like it used to be. It is now soft and lush (new) but still full with deep color and lot of texture. Some cranberry, cherry and hints at cassis with some watermelon too. It’s a decent drink but not like it used to be and it is sweeter. A new audience will enjoy it but the old one is going to be disappointed. Tasted twice with consistent notes. I’ll try again next year. More of a cocktail wine now than a food wine.$12